Phantom Blade Zero Reviews ARE IN: Why Did Eurogamer Give it 3/5?
Phantom Blade 0 reviews are officially live, and while the game is dominating with a 91 on OpenCritic, a controversial 3/5 review from Eurogamer is single-handedly tanking the Metacritic average and robbing it of the "Must Play" badge. Welcome to the Reforge Gaming live review round-up! S-Game’s highly anticipated Wuxia action-RPG releases on October 29, and critics are universally praising its blisteringly fast combat and spectacular boss fights, scoring it above heavy hitters like Nioh 3 and Onimusha: Way of the Sword. But we need to talk about the elephant in the room: Eurogamer's harsh 3/5 score. In today's stream, we’re breaking down the highest and lowest scores to find the truth. Is this 3/5 a legitimate critique of linear level design and technical performance, or is games media just trying to farm engagement by being the lone outlier? We'll also dive into the game's mechanics, how the combat loop compares to the best action games of the year, and whether this solidifies Phantom Blade Zero as a true Game of the Year contender. Join the live chat and let us know: Does a Metacritic score even matter anymore, or is the critic review system completely broken? Topics Covered: Phantom Blade Zero Metacritic & OpenCritic scores revealed Breaking down the Eurogamer 3/5 review controversy How the combat and mechanics compare to Nioh 3 and Onimusha PC and PS5 Pro performance reports (Frame rates, PSSR, and stutters) Is Phantom Blade 0 a GOTY contender? #PhantomBladeZero #PhantomBlade0 #PS5 #GameReviews #ReforgeGaming #GamingNews #Metacritic
Published: Oct 26, 2026